Friday, December 13, 2013

Social Deconstruction Project: Wolves Part 1

Species Identification
I have chosen the gray wolf (Canis lupis) as my species for this project. Grey wolves are a wildlife species present in the northernmost parts of the United States and most of Canada.
Social History
The relationship between humans and wolves can be traced back longer than recorded history. Early humans contended with wolves for animals to hunt. Later when humans gained agricultural skills, wolves posed a threat to livestock. This in particular has helped create the concept of the sly, deceptive wolf in the collective folklore of many countries. Over our shared history wolves have often been persecuted and vilified by humans. Hunting wolves has been done out of necessity, as well as for sport. To this day they remain an often misunderstood animal.
Not all of the interactions between early humans and wolves were competitive however. Wolves were the first species ever domesticated by humans. The exact timing of this is unknown, but is estimated to be between 15,000 and 33,000 years ago. The process by which this occurred is also unknown. However, the main theories behind this are the self-domestication theory and the orphaned wolf-cub theory. The self-domestication theory proposes that wolves with a lessened fear of humans could more readily approach human encampments to scrounge for food; leading to an evolution of tamer wolves. The orphaned wolf-cub theory, on the other hand, makes the claim that wolf cubs, which are more easily socialized and tamed, were adopted by humans after their parents had been killed. Both of these theories have some amount of experimental evidence supporting them and the truth is likely that a mix of both occurred.

Current Social Perception
Wolves do not serve a specific function to humankind. They are not a livestock species meant to provide meat or milk. However the role they play in nature is much larger than many realize. Across their vast range, wolves are often a keystone predator and vital to their ecosystem. Wolves control populations of many species, such as lynxes and cougars. Wolves also interact with other predators through competitive exclusion. Wolves may sometimes try to scavenge kills from brown bears or tigers; this can lead to both species having a limiting effect on the other’s population.
            Despite the role they play in the ecosystem, and their relatively small part in our lives, wolves are still often viewed as frightful or intimidating. Portrayals of wolves in popular TV and movies such as “The Hobbit” or “The Grey” portray wolves as violent killers. Although these are fantastical representations, they still have an effect in shaping public perception of these animals.
            Public perception of wolves is not all bad. There is a large group of people who understand wolves and their value. Groups such as The Wolf Conservation Center, The NatioWildlife Federation, Wolf Haven International, and multiple national parks work towards the conservation and recovery of wolves in areas were their numbers have been threatened. These groups also help to increase public knowledge about wolves and dispel negative myths and stereotypes, giving these creatures some much needed PR.
n al

Intelligence and Emotions
Multiple reports and lab studies have demonstrated that wolves are intelligent creatures. They have the ability to remember and associate events as well as to learn. During the extermination of the American bison, wolves learned to associate gunshots with carcasses that would be left behind by hunters after skinning them. Other studies have demonstrated that non-rabid wolves can distinguished between armed and unarmed humans as well as detect self-confident demeanors. Wolves that have been exposed to traps have repeatedly showed that they learn how to avoid or trigger them without harm.
Wolves respond better to hand cues than vocal cues
            Wolves are even trainable, although they are less responsive than dogs. Wolves seem to have a much stronger sense of independence and prefer to serve their own needs than please a human. This has been demonstrated by wolves that get bored after performing the same command several times and stop responding, or wolves that have been trained as sled dogs which, once tired, stop and refuse to listen further.
            Wolves also have been shown to display emotions. The most concrete evidence of this is their physical posturing. Wolves use multiple cues to express their mood, similar to dogs. Barred teeth and upright, forward pointing ears indicate a dominant threat. Meanwhile, closed mouths and pulled back ears indicate a submissive state of being. Much like dogs, wolves also use their tails to express themselves. Threatened wolves hold their tails up high, while submissive wolves keep their tail tucked between their legs.




Speciesism
Wolves are subject to speciesism through their treatment as a menace and extermination. Throughout history, wolves have been persecuted and in some cases systematically exterminated. The organized efforts to exterminate wolves have succeeded in several cases. Japan killed off the last wolf on their island chain in 1905, despite the animals being considered gods in Shinto mythology. Northern Europe also made it a point to exterminate wolves during the middle ages, doing so in England, Scotland, and Ireland.
            To my knowledge, wolves are the only mammal to be systematically exterminated purely because they are considered a nuisance. Wolves have received a level of persecution not given to other species. Despite their important role in the ecosystem or their past relationships with humans that led to their domestication and the creation of the modern dog, wolves have been devalued as a species. Although species such as bovines, poultry, or fish are killed in larger numbers, they are done so as food and considered to serve a purpose. Wolves were not exterminated for food but because they proved inconvenient to humans.

References
Grandin, Temple; Johnson, Catherine (2005). Animals in Translation. New York, New York: Scribner. p. 87. ISBN 0-7432-4769-8.
 O. Thalmann et al. (2013). Complete Mitochondrial Genomes of Ancient Canids Suggest a European Origin of Domestic Dogs. Science 15 November 2013: Vol. 342 no. 6160 pp. 871-874 DOI: 10.1126/science.1243650.
Viegas, Jennifer (date = October 17, 2008). "MSNBC : World's first dog lived 31,700 years ago, ate big". Discovery News (MSNBC).
Fulbright, Timothy E. & Hewitt, David G. (2007) Wildlife Science: Linking Ecological Theory and Management Applications, CRC PressISBN 0-8493-7487-1, p. 118
 Heptner, V. G. & Sludskii, A. A. Mammals of the Soviet Union: Carnivora (hyaenas and cats), Volume 2 (1992), BRILL, ISBN 90-04-08876-8
 Sunquist, Melvin E. & Sunquist, Fiona (2002) Wild cats of the world, University of Chicago Press, p. 167 ISBN 0-226-77999-8
Grooms, Steve (2010). "Cougar Wolf Interactions: It's a Lot Like Cats and Dogs". International Wolf 20 (2): 8–11.
 Mech & Boitani 2003, pp. 264–65
Geist, Valerius (2006) When do Wolves become Dangerous to Humans?, The University of Calgary.
Heptner & Naumov 1998, pp. 244–245
Mech & Boitani 2003, pp. 63–65
Mech 1981, pp. 8–9
"Are wolves and wolfdog hybrids trainable?". Wolf Park. Archived from the original on 2008-06-15. Retrieved 2008-10-30.
 Zimen 1981, pp. 88–90

No comments:

Post a Comment